Sunday, May 24, 2020

Covid-19, in India, an Analysis

Collated a series of strong articles (mostly posted on FB), that illustrate India's dire situation. It requires course correction, to salvage losing more lives. 

  1. Great Natual Calamity
  2. Useless self-inflicted wounds
  3. Solution is save each other, we disunited. 

If this is not done soon, India is headed towards crores of deaths by next year, with tri-hits of corona, hunger, and strife. To see how, keep reading till the end. 

1. Science of Epidemics - Great Natural Calamity

Everyone in Policy must understand, otherwise, you will not just be fooled, you are fooling yourself. 

1.1 Simulation Analysis

Simulating an Epidemic, elucidated easily, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxAaO2rsdIs&t=18s

1.2 Fighting Strategy 


Wonderful series of scientific articles with evidences, the best on Coronavirus, with timely guidance to seekers: esp recommend Hammer-and-the-dance strategy to control. 

  1. 10Mar'20: Coronavirus: Why you must Act Now      https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-act-today-or-people-will-die-f4d3d9cd99ca
  2. 20Mar'20: Coronavirus, The Hammer and the Dance: The strategy every country must follow https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-hammer-and-the-dance-be9337092b56
  3. 02Apr'20: Coronavirus: Out of Many, One: A deep dive in the US https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-out-of-many-one-36b886af37e9
  4. 20Apr'20: Coronavirus: Learning How to Dance: How the best countries are fighting the epidemic https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-learning-how-to-dance-b8420170203e
  5. 23Apr'20: Coronavirus: The Basic Dance Steps Everybody Can Follow https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-basic-dance-steps-everybody-can-follow-b3d216daa343
  6. 28Apr'20: Coronavirus: How to do Testing and Contact Tracing https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-how-to-do-testing-and-contact-tracing-bde85b64072e

1.3 Quick Primer on controlling an epidemic


To local administrators, a quick primer on controlling an epidemic..

R-effective = effective Reproduction number = measures the average number of people that would be infected by a single infectious person, taking into account the public health interventions implemented to control the spread of virus.

"Reff > 1 means an outbreak is likely" (larger/smaller only differentiates faster/slower)

"A *sustained* value of Reff < 1 means the virus will be eliminated from the community."

Until eliminated, "you can’t ever relax when it comes to coronavirus."

2. Self-inflicted, Useless, Irreversible Damage 

"Destroy the free market, and you create a black market; 
you overwhelm the people with laws and regulations,
and you induce a general disrespect of law. ", Winston Churchill. 

2.0 Report Card:

A look at Covid19 case growth (https://aatishb.com/covidtrends),
superimposed with 1,2,3,7,14,31-day doubling trend-lines (by me). 
Required: WIN against Covid19: Get-Out of exponential zone, and Stay-Out. 

Lockdown, an extreme intervention to cut/remove cases, used too early, and being celebrated only mere slow growth. It delayed epidemic by a month or two, but made people malnourished and India disunited, in the fight of building Herd immunity. These couple of months made us weak, and lot more will die now of disease, not counting additional deaths of starvation and civil strife.

Worst hit are countries that ignored, then did ineffective lockdowns. Social distancing must come from people, not by force. More of it in next section.

2.1 Economic 

The economic damage of the way lockdown was implemented, is not lower growth, or recession, but is irreversible damage.
https://indianexpress.com/article/business/economy/67-of-workers-lost-jobs-during-lockdown-survey-by-azim-premji-university-6407333/

Hear a migrant labourer summarize  https://www.facebook.com/100003223541842/videos/2923490984434991/
Migrant workers are so distressed, that they want to die in their villages, rather than return to cities. These hardworking labourers, came to cities to earn living, have lost their honour begging for food.

2.3 It Cost Humanity

I am cutting short the section, because the amount of suffering is huge to document even in a full book by itself.
https://www.facebook.com/100008758771095/videos/2295560220745915

2.3 Medical Disasters


Medical disasters in Indian response to Coronavirus (Economic is another topic), all of which indicate very short thinking:
  1. Feb: Ignoring the threat in high pride - keeping airports open, bringing Indians from disaster zones, having Namaste Trump.
  2. March: Stigmatizing desease victims, there by moving it underground & inhibiting people from coming fwd.
  3. Apr: Govts fighting to show low numbers by running away from testing. It's ridiculous, as not counting doesn't mean people will not die next month.
  4. May: Rushing to throw social distancing along with lockdown. 
  5. Data underreporting: Lakhs die in India each year. covid deaths are currently very low in comparison, but it has exponential growth. Sooner or later, it'll overtake, when you'll realise fudged data misreported. By then, most of India would be exposed, with huge masses infected, with some dead and others waiting for their death. Nothing can then be done, except rue to data fudging of today. 

3. Reason: Solution =Save each other, Action = Disunited


3.1 Solution

In Ibn Sina's words (1st Epidemiologist, who invented quarantine), 
1. Fight Fear, 2. don't panic 3. gain its understanding 4. avoid gatherings

3.2 People need to solve it, not state

Social distancing must come from the people, they must do in their personal lives. Govt can facilitate it by providing their needs, so they can afford to stay put, shelter in place. 


Read in Times 1Apr, "Stigmatizing of patients hampers contact tracing". Seems it has become People vs Govt. No crisis can be solved with disarray in ranks. 
The govt is not trying/willing to communicate, instead wielding stick. 

  • 2 India's can't separately fight corona & hunger. 
  • While govt do lockdown, damn the daily earners & SMEs; 
  • Poor protest for food in lockdown, damn social distancing.
Failure: Govt fighting Epidemic, Business fighting Lockdown, People fighting starvation. 

Easy Success: Govt disown lockdown, Business lift economy, People trained resist Epidemic. 

  • A.Medical staff & Administration fighting against Corona.1 
  • B.SME entrepreneurs & Daily wagers fighting Disarray.2
  • C.Community (& Religious) leaders fighting mass Hunger.3
A1,B2,C3.. Non-winnable plays.

#SwitchTheGames .. A2,B3,C1. It's a breeze.

3.2 How Collective solutioning works

 A teacher brought balloons to school and asked the children to blow them all up and then each write their names on their balloon. They tossed all the balloons into the hall while the teacher mixed them from one end to the other.  The teacher then gave them 5 minutes to find the balloon with their name on it. The children ran around, looking frantically but as the time ran out - nobody had found their own balloon…

Then the teacher told them to take the balloon closest to them and give it to the person who’s name was on it.  In less than 2 minutes everyone had their own balloon. Finally the teacher said, “Balloons are like happiness. No one will find it looking for theirs only. Instead if everyone cares about each others they will find theirs as quickly as possible.” 🎈

3.3 Warning

https://www.facebook.com/atif.hussain.63/posts/10163283695450611
  1. 1020 Spanish Flu killed 1.8 crore Indians.
  2. 1200s Mongols destroying food supply chains is believed to have killed crores.
  3. 1947 India partition riots killed another 1 crore.
At risk is 2020, seeing all three happening together - Coronavirus + Lockdown + PoliceBrutality.

My recommendations, to prevent
  • Brutality : CopsOffOurStreets, let them rest now.
  • Lockdown : remove enforcement, spread awareness.
  • Coronavirus : need to fight together, 85% mild cured carriers coming fwd with blood donation to treat 15% serious patients.
This needs healing ruptures in society. Till then, Indians surrender to SARS-CoV-2 + Fear + Cruelty.