a. The Islamic and the Modern Western systems, especially the Economic system on which I am qualified to comment, are entirely different and incompatible
b. The early Muslim scholars and the Caliphate period clearly laid down the Islamic jurisprudence system (shariah) for an Islamic state
c. Muslim subjects of un-Islamic states, are to follow shariah in all personal matters, leaving state matters based on un-Islamic systems. This is piece-wise Islam.
d. Islamic laws are based on establishing an equitable society. Piece-wise Islam does not achieve that goal. Moreover, acts like – paying both income tax and wealth tax (zakat), not taking interest but giving interest due to compulsions – work to the detriment of Muslims in the land, and in favor of other selfish exploiters there. A direct effect of this is that Muslims are poorer than non-Muslims across the world as well as their own countrymen.
e. Piece-wise Islam was invented during prophet-hood and caliphate periods itself, but as a temporary means for very transient time periods. But it has unfortunately been widely expanded since then.
f. This system of piece-wise Islam was actually largely abrogated by an open call for and an injunction to Muslims to migrate to the Islamic state (No such state exists today). Only reasons for Muslims to remain outside this state were temporary sojourns &/or for spread of Islam
g. Contemporary Muslim leaders & scholars seem to unanimously direct Muslims to follow this piece-wise Islam while continuing to live in non-Islamic environment. It is to be noted here that Muhammad (s.a.w) and his companions had very few Islamic practices to follow while they lived under Polytheist’s rule at Mecca.
h. Pursuit of Islam ought to be along – bringing more people into the fold, practicing Islam where we are free to follow (definitely not economics), and establishment of at least an Islamic compliant state for practicing other Islamic orders – instead of a half baked approach to Islam which is semi-integrating and stagnating Muslim community.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment