The author recommends to Form alliances, and addresses with who, how, and how much to give in alliance forming.
In a vast and diverse democracy like India, alliances form an integral part of the election campaign. With a diverse electoral base, there are bound to be multitudes of opinions, and one set of opinions across policy fields cannot cater to all. The dominant and popular opinion in each policy field evolves as a result of the election process, amidst give and take of alliances.
In a national common electorate with proportional representation, each opinion is considered in this post-election alliance forming, after component parties have proven their strengths in the election.
In first-past-the-post elections, like India's local constituencies, or US's state representatives, elections in each constituency becomes bipolar (though technically multipolar, voters equate voting for 3rd and lower candidates as a NOTA or vote waste), and alliance formations need to be done before elections. Therein forming Alliances becomes a game theory play.
Game theory predisposes towards those with better information, giving rise to effective election analysts and backroom poll strategists in India. US system has evolved where both leading parties conduct primaries to measure backing for opinions and form alliances before the final election. Republican party which was then week, allying with and absorbing tea-party candidates was one such example.
In India, with so many small constituencies influenced by local effects, it's impossible to accurately measure voter pulse, and alliance formations depend on successful negotiations in a game theory. Against a strong candidate or party, it is important for other parties or candidates to form mutual benefit alliances. However, when both parties are optimistic about their prospects, compromises can't be achieved. Even if one is over optimistic, reasonable benefit cannot be provided to the other to form the alliance. It is this that I like to discuss and address.
The first aspect is who alliances can be formed with. Everyone. Nobody is untouchable in political democracy. Though alliances may be termed as opportunistic alliances of convenience to retain power, they are real alliances with those closest to your ideological and opinion spectrum on most important policies. Such alliances, it must be noted and understood, are objective compromises to meet end goals of least bad and most favored option, when public opinion is divided in free society. Two such parties are never enemies of each other, as they both represent people of the same constituencies. Nor is it ever a full policy alignment, otherwise these parties would not be distinct.
Consider unity of all parties against INC's authoritarian rule and emergency in 1970s. And then 1990s considerations of centrist INC allying with rightist BJP to keep left and regional groups at bay and provide stable central government. And then far leftist Communist parties supporting centrist INC in 2004 to keep rightist BJP out. Such alliance formations based on social economic parameters are much more overt and publicly discussed in other countries.
The second aspect of resolving the alliance arithmetic is information, and collective gathering so agreement can be had based on it. This reduces the game play between partners, so they do not sabotage each other to assert each other in alliances thus formed. Consider breakup of BJP-SS, INC-NCP alliances before 2014 Maharashtra elections, and their uneasy alliance for next 5 years. Having shared surveys and voter pulse gathering would at least remove disagreement about facts and vote base estimate about each other.
The third and most important is how and what alliance arithmetic to form between similar yet different parties, that best serves to further their ideologies, instead of risking sabotaging each other towards the opposite ideology. Trying to address the what arithmetic first is prone to disagreements and show of strengths, resulting in sabotaging each other and breakdown of negotiations. I am of the strong opinion that how part should be addressed first, and the what arithmetic easily follows.
How to form alliance. India is a parliamentary government. It is not one election, but 543 local elections, formed of different groups of people, with different priorities. Priorities of drought prone Tamil Nadu, Jharkhand villages, Naxal affected Chattisgarh, and urban Mumbai, is and will be different, and alliance question in each should be treated on its own merits. So alliances should be formed regional and sub-regional, or 1-on-1 give in one constituency and take in another.
Treating each constituency independently, helps filter out the constituencies where either party is already confident of winning and does not want to compromise. Similarly, in multiparty alliances, constituencies where two parties are collectively comfortable need not include a third partner. This boils down to the constituencies where you are independently not sure and alliances can help prospects. Left over constituencies are subject to negotiations and game play. Here, alliance must be seen as a means to further your position and reject the opposing position. Where not competitive, not fighting and sitting out, is better than fighting and cutting votes of a partially aligned opinion in favor of a fully opposite position.
In this game of open seats, each looses if they don't ally. Collectively gain if ally. Individual gain is subject to bargaining. As both share equal benefit, rationally, both benefit from alliance, and it does not matter who has how much individual influence. But unlike BJP-INC-JDS trilogy, where numbers are known and dependency is forced, before an election, the exact numbers are not yet known, and optimistic/pessimistic possibilities exist. Because each is trying to achieve highest votes in first-past-the-post, the best normative recommendation is to share alliance seats in each sub-region according to their proportional vote share.
When voter opinion is much more uncertain, another approach is to divide some seats and contest some. Example, two parties A and B, can divide one seat each in an alliance and contest on the third. Optimistically, they had gain 2, but pessimistically they'd still gain 1 and not sabotage on the 3rd.
Hope i had see an election where our parties push for themselves rather than denouncing the other. After all, no one knows the outcome, and there are no untouchables in politics.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment