Many well-intended schemes to support them have been unable to break this scenario. Crop Insurance, though launched in multiple scheme variants since 2000, does not find attractive to farmers. Loan waivers act as only one time support, and not able to cover all loans due to state's financial constraints. MSP again has been a huge cost on exchequer and leaves out those whose crop failed. Subsidies in fertilizer and pesticides drives overuse in food chain with little to show in output. We shall understand the economics of farm market and see what is happening.
Demand-Supply Curve Isoquants
Consider the market for an agriculture good, which normally would have balanced Demand and Supply curves (fig1). And a simplified view of the input factors to produce a given output (fig2), which always has declining input efficiencies for excess use of any resource - be it land, labor, seeds, or fertilizer or pesticide. A free market, left to itself, without interventions, should reach Demand=Supply equilibrium, with market determined prices.
In the DS market equilibrium, prices would be stable in the long term. However in the short run, there is lag in supply (seeding to harvest time). While Demand remains highly inelastic, Supply Qeq cannot change once seed is sown. This causes prices to heavily fluctuate with seasonal & cyclical swings.
- By subsidizing a particular farming input, like fertilizers or pesticides, we are promoting excessive use of chemicals in farming, for the same amount of output.
- The effect of MSP changes after a season is sowed, is financial outlay to the farmers, proportional to their produce, but with no side-effect. MSP set before the sowing season, results in an equilibrium on DS graph between supply curve and a flat MSP price curve, independent of the Demand curve. If this MSP is above Demand, then there would be huge over production, with govt forced to buy not just this overproduce, but the entire production, at a price significantly above market price, resulting a huge financial drain. So MSP results in either of these 3 scenarios - low MSP of no value, high MSP which cannot be financially sustained by govt, and high govt MSP with no govt credibility.
- Crop insurance, like any insurance, can only hedge risks, by paying from good yields, but not improve expected returns. And with low financial awareness, insurance forms a very ill fit solution to illiterate farmers.
- Loan waiver
Why are these solutions so difficult and costly.
Consider Farming as any other macro-market, with output, Crop Revenue = acreage * yield * price. This market, like any, works to self balance. The populace is mostly predetermined (exports/imports form a miniscule), the factor allocated to consumption are set. Price auto adjusts to varying output. Though acreage, yield and price fluctuate heavily, crop revenue changes little. Instead of addressing crop revenue, various existing schemes address one of the high variation factors - MSP to price, insurance to yield, subsidies overuse acreage and loan waivers reward acreage overuse.
Most of past and present policies failed as they were designed to support all farming. We must accept that farmers are entrepreneurs, and not all farming can be made viable. Once this mindset is accepted & spread, we can better see core issues as they are - anticipation, and humiliation on failure.
So we should encourage farmers towards financial literacy, where anticipation is rational. Make policies & rural culture different on loan recoveries, to remove fear of failure. Entrepreneurs and farmers are a necessity to society, so we should permit them to take calculated risks and fail. To enable this, we must free our markets for better price discovery.
Forwards in agricultural Commodities with local markets.


No comments:
Post a Comment